Making predictions! Pregnant Hilary Duff doesn’t know the sex of her and Matthew Koma‘s baby-to-be — but she’s “stoked and super excited” either way.

“Everyone that’s close to me thinks boy, and then everyone that’s more of a stranger that’s like, ‘What are you having?’ they’re like, ‘We call girl,’” the Younger star, 33, said during the Thursday, March 18, “Informed Pregnancy Podcast” episode. “Honestly, I’m just saying boy. I really don’t have a strong feeling about it either way, which made me feel guilty for the longest time. I was like, ‘I should know, it’s inside my body. It’s my baby, I should know.’”

The actress is “now OK with just not knowing.” The Lizzie McGuire alum noted that she would be a “little scared” to welcome another baby girl after 2-year-old daughter Banks’ October 2018 birth.